Author: David A. Hill
I’d like to start by asking you to consider four quotations:
- “ We learn to read by reading.” (Smith: 1985)
- “Reading…must be developed and can only be developed, by means of extensive and continual practice.” (Eskey: 1986)
- “We must…. make a clear distinction between the building up of particular skills and strategies, or of relevant knowledge, and reading itself. Both top-down and bottom-up skills can, in the long run, only be developed by extensive reading over time. Classroom work can point the way but cannot substitute for the act itself: people learn to read by reading, not by doing exercises.”
(Eskey/Grabe in Carrell et al: 1988)
- “It is first of all the teacher who must create the world of reading in a particular class. It is the teacher who must stimulate interest in reading, who must project his or her enthusiasm for books, and who must help students to see that reading can be of real value to them.” (Eskey/Grabe in Carrell et al: 1988)
What these writers say seems to me to clearly point to the need for extensive reading in the language curriculum, if we want our students to become competent readers in the target language.
Some research results
I would like to draw your attention to the results from the following three extensive reading projects reported in
- The Fiji “Book Flood” (1980-81: Elley)
- Learners involved: 500 9-11 year olds in 12 schools (8 experimental/4 control)
- each experimental school had: 250 story books and 20-30 minutes reading for pleasure daily
- after 2 years, the experimental school pupils were ‘far superior in tests of reading comprehension, writing and grammar’
- The Singapore “Book Flood” (1985-88: Elley)
- Learners involved: 3,000 6-9 year olds
- after 3 years the children “outperformed traditionally taught students on tests of reading comprehension, vocabulary, oral language, grammar, listening comprehension and writing.”
- The Singapore PASSES project (1985-1990: Davis)
- Learners involved: 40 of the weakest secondary schools
- each school had a daily 20-minute reading period
- books were available for reading at home
- the Project “succeeded in raising the schools’ English language pass rate at ‘O’-level above the national average”.
- “Pupils developed a wider active and passive vocabulary. They used more varied sentence structure, and were better at spotting and correcting grammatical mistakes in their writing and speaking. They showed an overall improvement in writing skills and increased confidence and fluency in speaking.”
- “Any ESL, EFL or L1 classroom will be the poorer for the lack of an extensive reading programme of some kind, and will be unable to promote its pupils’ language development in all aspects as effectively as if such a programme were present. This is true at every level..”
I find these results compelling evidence of the need for extensive reading to be a central part of every language learning curriculum. In my experience, teachers generally assume that extensive reading helps the students became better readers and expands their vocabulary, however these results show that all areas of language learning are affected positively.
A major element of in the success of these programmes, however, is the way in which the reading was done. It cannot be stressed clearly enough that for such programmes to work, the students have to presented with books which they would like to read (not those which the teacher wants them to read!). They have to be allowed to read at their own pace, and be given time in and out of class to read. When they have read a book, the right kind of post-reading activities need to be used. For example, if you’ve just finished reading Ian McEwan’s Mann Booker Prize shortlisted novel On Chesil Beach, you don’t want somebody asking you what colour pullover the protagonist was wearing at the start of the story, do you? You want to be asked what you thought of the story, whether you found it interesting, amusing, true to life, what the writing was like and so on. It is imperative not to use the common type of classroom intensive reading activities after extensive reading.
Intensive Reading and Extensive Reading
Let me make it very clear that I am not saying intensive reading is not necessary, and that we should only do extensive reading with learners. Far from it. Done correctly, class-based intensive reading work feeds the right kind of skills into extensive reading, building up the students text attack abilities over time. But teachers need to be aware of the great differences between the two types of reading. The table below characterises those differences.
|INTENSIVE READING||EXTENSIVE READING|
|Reading the text is an end in itself||Reading the text is a means to an end|
|The text is read for maximum comprehension||The text is read for general comprehension|
|The text is read in the classroom||The text is read outside the classroom|
|Students do many exercises which require them to work in depth on various aspects of the text||Students may do exercises which consist of reports, summaries, discussions and debates|
|The teacher provides direction before, during and after reading||The students choose what texts to read and how they want to read them|
Intensive reading can often be done through the kind of activities offered in the average course book. Extensive reading is rarely included in course books, although those with long ELT memories might recall the power of the famous story The Man Who Escaped in Robert O’Neill et al’s Kernel Lessons Intermediate published by Longman in the 1970s. The students had usually finished the story a few weeks into the course, whereas it was intended to be read in weekly installments as the grammatical course developed!!
The Characteristics of an Extensive Reading Approach
In setting up an extensive reading programme in a school English department, the following characteristics are desirable:
- Students read as much as possible
- A variety of material is available
- Students select what they want to read
- The purposes of reading are: pleasure, information and general understanding
- Reading is its own reward
- Reading materials are within the students’ competence
- Reading is individual and silent
- The teacher’s role is to explain the aims of the programme and the methodology, keep records of what the students have read, guide students to get the most out of their reading, act as a role-model.
Teachers often ask me how it is possible to make such a scheme work in under-resourced, poorly-financed schools. There are basically two options, of which the first is the most difficult: the school should set aside an annual budget for the purchase of a variety of suitable readers, which builds into a large library over, say, a five year period. A further point is that these days, many publishers are making CDs an integral part of the book, so that there are listening opportunities to reinforce the reading. Failing this, the second option is to ask each student to provide the money for one, or better two books each. These then become the class reading pool, and at the end of the year, the students take the books home. The teacher should order the books in consultation with the students, on the basis of what they want to read. This ensures diversity, and the purchase of books at the correct level. It may also be that the teacher can negotiate a suitable discount for a larger order with the local distributor.
In class, some time, however small, of each week’s time allocation for English needs to be given over to some aspect of the extensive reading being done. This might include students talking about a book they have read, doing suitable kinds of post-reading activities, such as discussing their book with others who have already read it, completing a wall-chart of books read, changing finished books for a new one, writing a book review and so on. This might be more possible in Brazilian private language schools, but given the limited time available in state schools for English, teachers may have to find some other alternative if they are really convinced of the value of extensive reading. One such possibility would be to have a 30-minute Reading Club session once a week or twice a month outside the normal school timetable.
My friend and one-time NILE colleague Alan Pulverness’s Guide (see below) will give you some useful ideas on the right kind of activities to use.
I hope you will feel inspired to set up an extensive reading programme for your students. If you would like to discuss any aspects of this with me, please feel free to email me at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Author: David A. Hill